Skip to Content
Capital Acumen Issue 30

Becoming A High Impact Philanthropist

To bring more focus to their giving, wealthy donors are drilling down, checking up and reaching out.

Hands holding a gift on a table

American philanthropy is undergoing a revolution. Wealthy donors who might once have been content to send an annual check, trusting in charitable organizations to use funds effectively, now want to be more involved — and more targeted — in their giving. What’s behind this shift to so-called high impact philanthropy?

Some philanthropists believe that in recent years government agencies have fallen short in such areas as improving education, and addressing hunger and poverty, and feel compelled to step in to help. Others may be influenced by professional business practices, where donors expect the use of metrics and data to create transparency and accountability. Board members are being asked to use their expertise not just for fundraising but also for sound governance and operating efficiency. Meanwhile, more information — particularly via the Internet — has given philanthropists a view of a new set of potential, immediate outcomes. At the same time, many donors still have questions about their giving.

Donor Experience

As part of the philanthropy group at U.S. Trust, we’re often approached by clients seeking answers to a wide range of questions, including: Where and how much are my peers donating? Should I give to more than one organization? Can I use more than one giving vehicle?

Headshot of Ann Limberg

Photograph by Eric Mcnatt

 

Wealthy donors now want to be more involved and targeted in their giving.

Some clients are looking for ways to involve other generations in the family’s philanthropic goals. In those cases, we typically encourage them to clearly define their family’s values using a series of customized questions and exercises or to create a philanthropic mission, which can help drill down to what’s relevant for the family.

Uniting in this way can be helpful when a family is geographically separated or has a history of problematic relationships. If each generation has its own independent assets, families that work to discover common goals and a shared mission can often pool these assets to create a greater immediate impact and improve more lives. Similarly, by understanding their children’s philanthropic goals, parents can guide them to charities in line with those goals.

Three Case Studies About Focused Giving

Giving as a family

Two clients started a family foundation based on their shared charitable interests. They wanted to engage their teenage children in their philanthropic goals and turned to U.S. Trust for help.

We suggested they create a mission statement together and gave them exercises designed to help the family articulate their philanthropic values and interests. While working on that, the parents learned about their children's philanthropic goals and decided to explore an expanded set of charitable interests. They asked us to work with them to uncover a number of charities working in the areas of their kids' interests.

Giving with connections

A client who was newly appointed as the president of a large private foundation focused on education was interested in connecting with like-minded clients. She wanted to discuss their shared funding initiatives and experiences. Given the complexity of public education reform, it made sense co connect her with experienced funders who understood the nuances of the sector, potential partners and peers. U.S. Trust was able to help set them up.

Giving with variety

A client wanted to continue making annual donations to a large nonprofit group focused on healthcare, and she also hoped to target childhood education. We helped her open an account in a donor-advised food focusing on Education, to which she went on to donate cash and securities.

Closer Ties

Wealthy donors, including those with limited experience in high impact giving, may seek to connect with like-minded philanthropists or charitable organizations. In those cases, U.S. Trust may bring both parties together in one way or another — through in-person meetings, phone calls or the like. A highly effective way to learn more about an organization, we may tell clients, can be to volunteer — perhaps by raising funds or joining its board.

Traditionally, nonprofits have maintained hierarchical relationships with donors. However, many are now responding to the requirements of modern giving by becoming not only more transparent but also more collaborative with donors, knowing that stronger ties can often lead to longer-term financial commitments.

Ways To Give

“Focused giving” may sound like it involves giving in only one way. In fact, it is not uncommon for a focused donor to use a variety of giving vehicles. That may mean donating directly to a nonprofit organization, funding a charitable trust where beneficiaries can include a nonprofit group and loved ones, giving to a donor-advised fund where donors can be involved in directing contributions, or creating and funding a private foundation of their own.

Related Insights

Back to Top